Pure Benchmarks · Hypotheticals
Panic Selling vs Staying Invested, Measured on Your Own Portfolio
Motley Fool, Bloomberg, Questrade, and virtually every financial publication agree — panic selling is costly and staying invested is the right long term strategy. That advice is correct. It is also completely generic. It tells you nothing about whether staying invested is the right call for your specific portfolio right now, based on how your specific holdings have actually performed through previous stress events compared to real investors in the same situation. Hartford Funds confirmed 76 percent of the market's best single days occur during a bear market or within the first two months of a bull market recovery. DALBAR found investors correctly timed market entries and exits only 25 percent of the time in 2024, tying a record low. Pure Benchmarks shows how your specific portfolio performed through every previous market stress event since you linked your account, compared to thousands of real verified investors in the same risk category — replacing generic advice with objective data about your own history.
Link your portfolio and see, in dollars, what your own holdings would have done if you had held through past crashes instead of selling. Every sale and re-entry after that is scored against staying invested.
See Your Free Benchmark ReportWhere generic advice runs out
Every major publication reaches the same conclusion, and that conclusion is correct on average. It still cannot tell you how your particular holdings behaved through a particular selloff, or whether investors like you fared better.
Why the timing is the hard part
Hartford Funds found 76 percent of the market's best single days occur during a bear market or within the first two months of a bull market recovery, which is why exiting and re-entering is so costly. DALBAR found investors correctly timed entries and exits only 25 percent of the time in 2024, tying a record low.
The two paths, priced on your real holdings
Each stress event in your history is priced two ways — holding through it, and selling into it then buying back in — so the comparison is made with the positions you actually owned rather than an index stand-in.
What the peer view adds
Your result is set against thousands of real verified investors in the same risk category who faced the same conditions, so you can see whether your outcome was typical, better, or worse.
Link your portfolio and see, in dollars, what your own holdings would have done if you had held through past crashes instead of selling. Every sale and re-entry after that is scored against staying invested.
See Your Free Benchmark ReportFrequently asked questions
Is staying invested always better than selling?
Not always, and this report does not assume it. Each selloff in your history is priced both ways and reported honestly, including the cases where selling would have produced the better outcome.
What percentage of the market's best days happen during downturns?
Hartford Funds found 76 percent of the market's best single days occur during a bear market or within the first two months of a bull market recovery, which is why exiting and re-entering is difficult to do profitably.
Does Wikipedia explain what panic selling costs individual investors?
Wikipedia provides a clear definition of panic selling as a market-wide phenomenon but does not offer tools to calculate what panic selling cost an individual investor specifically. Pure Benchmarks Hypotheticals fills that gap using real portfolio data.
Does Motley Fool have a panic selling analysis tool?
Motley Fool publishes extensive advice about avoiding panic selling but does not offer a personalized analysis tool. Pure Benchmarks is the only platform that calculates what panic selling cost your specific portfolio during real historical market selloffs compared to real verified investors who held through the same conditions.
Where can I find a free panic selling calculator?
Pure Benchmarks provides a free personalized panic selling analysis using your real connected portfolio data. No other free tool compares your panic selling outcome to real verified investors in the same risk category who held through the same market conditions at the same time.
Keep exploring
- How Much Is Holding Cash in My Portfolio Costing Me?
- Should I Sell My Stocks Before the Next Market Crash?
- What Happens If I Sell and Miss the Market Recovery?
- The Market Already Dropped. Is It Too Late to Sell?
See where a specific firm's portfolios stand:
New here? Read the portfolio benchmarking FAQ or the Pure Benchmarks blog.
This page is an information baseline for comparison only. It is not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy, sell, replace, or transfer any specific asset, account, or firm. Past performance does not guarantee future results. All figures shown are illustrative.