Pure Benchmarks · Portfolio Benchmark Report
Is Your Tastytrade Portfolio Underperforming?
Tastytrade is a large brokerage where the mix of self-directed holdings, managed products, and idle cash drives how closely the account tracks an index.
Pure Benchmarks ranks real Tastytrade portfolios against thousands of other verified investor portfolios across nine standardized risk categories, from 100% equity to 90% fixed income. Every portfolio is recategorized daily from actual end-of-day holdings, and Community Nests shows exactly where your Tastytrade portfolio ranks against other real Tastytrade clients in the same risk category — built entirely from verified portfolio data, with no firm that manages money able to see any data point on the platform.
Why your Tastytrade portfolio can lag a pure index baseline
The default-settings drag. Large brokerages often route uninvested cash into a default sweep that earns close to nothing, while in-house managed solutions carry their own expense ratios. Left on default settings, the gap against a pure index baseline widens quietly over time.
What to review on a Tastytrade portfolio
- Confirm whether holdings sit in higher-cost active funds rather than low-cost index funds.
- Compare how the overall allocation has tracked a diversified index baseline over time.
Illustrative 10-year comparison — a standard managed portfolio versus a pure index baseline. Figures are illustrative only.
| Year | Standard managed portfolio | Pure index baseline | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $105,200 | $107,000 | -$1,800 |
| Year 3 | $116,400 | $122,500 | -$6,100 |
| Year 5 | $128,700 | $140,300 | -$11,600 |
| Year 7 | $142,300 | $160,600 | -$18,300 |
| Year 10 | $165,100 | $196,700 | -$31,600 |
See exactly where your Tastytrade portfolio stands.
One clean report against a pure index baseline. No email required.
See Your Free Benchmark ReportCompare other firms
- Is your Charles Schwab Futures and Forex portfolio underperforming?
- Is your eOption portfolio underperforming?
- Is your Ally Financial portfolio underperforming?
- Is your Vanguard Brokerage Services portfolio underperforming?
- Is your Empower portfolio underperforming?
- Is your M1 Finance portfolio underperforming?
New here? Read the Pure Benchmarks blog or the portfolio benchmarking FAQ.
Answer the bigger questions
- Is Your Financial Advisor Doing a Good Job?
- What If You Had Switched Financial Advisors?
- How Do You Know If Your Portfolio Changes Worked?
- Can You Track Your Financial Advisor's Decisions?
- Are Your Financial Advisor's Decisions Working?
- How to Tell If Your Advisor Is Making Good Investment Decisions
- The Financial Advisor Decision Tracker Built for the Client
- Did Your Financial Advisor Make the Right Decisions?
This page is an information baseline for comparison only. It is not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy, sell, replace, or transfer any specific asset, account, or firm. Past performance does not guarantee future results. All figures shown are illustrative.